Share
You need valid and reliable data to make insightful conclusions and recommendations. But how do you get there when there are so many factors that introduce bias and errors in your data?
Treatment fidelity refers to how closely the survey adheres to the research protocol. This minimizes many common survey biases by ensuring that all questions are asked uniformly and that participants have equal opportunities to respond.
Let’s look at how to ensure your data collection accuracy and reliability with treatment fidelity.
Treatment fidelity in surveys is the extent to which the study is implemented as planned. It ensures the survey is conducted consistently and reliably across participants and settings.
Treatment fidelity allows you to establish and follow a uniform guideline for survey administration and data collection processes such as sampling, recruitment, consent, and data analysis.
Treatment fidelity also plays a key role in minimizing bias and error in data collection. If the survey is not conducted as planned, the results may be biased or inaccurate.
This is the process of developing the questionnaire and administering it. It includes selecting appropriate questions, responses, guidelines, and processes that align with the research goals and target population.
For example, if you want to measure customer satisfaction with a product, you have to design a survey that includes clear and relevant questions about the product’s features, perks, and limitations. You also have to decide the number of response options to indicate varying levels of satisfaction.
Related – Questionnaire Design: 10 Questioning Mistakes to Avoid
This involves following the survey’s instructions and protocols, such as the question order, the time allotted for each question, and the delivery method.
For example, if the instructions say to read each question aloud, then you need to do that. If the instructions say to give respondents 30 seconds to answer each question, then you need to do that.
You have to provide adequate information, guidance, and feedback to ensure interviewers understand the purpose, goals, and expectations of the survey. Start with how they introduce themselves, explain the survey objectives, obtain consent, and ask the questions.
You also have to monitor the survey administration process to ensure it is consistent with the guidelines. You can do this by observing indicators such as response rate, completion rate, item nonresponse, missing data, outliers, errors, and feedback from the respondents.
Fidelity is a key factor in the accuracy and reliability of a survey. If a survey isn’t conducted properly, then there’s a high probability of bias and inaccurate data.
For example, respondents may answer the questions out of context, without proper survey instructions, which reduces the validity and reliability of your results.
1. Interviewer Training and Monitoring
Interviewer training and monitoring are critical for guaranteeing treatment fidelity in survey research. This is because well-trained interviewers are more likely to ask questions correctly and to record data accurately.
Monitoring interviewer performance allows you to pinpoint errors and fix them before they impact the data’s accuracy. This includes regular feedback, supervision, and quality checks to ensure that the interviewers are following the protocols and scripts consistently.
2. Using a Detailed Protocol or Script
A protocol or script is a document that lays out exactly what questions to ask, the order to ask them, and how to ask them. It ensures all respondents are asked the same questions in the same.
Different Interviewers ask questions differently, so the responses they get and how they record results vary. This can lead to different interpretations of the questions and answers from participants, especially if the questions are sensitive, unclear, or vague.
You have to provide clear instructions and oversight to interviewers to prevent interviewer variability. Also, track their performance, give feedback, and employ well-defined routines and procedures.
Sure, not everyone who is invited to take the survey will take it. However, if the bulk of respondents only fit a specific demographic, it could result in data misinterpretation.
Design relevant, engaging, and user-intuitive surveys to counter non-response bias. For example, you can use multiple contact attempts, offer incentives, and assurances of confidentiality.
Read More: Response vs Nonresponse Bias in Surveys + [Examples]
Survey protocols are important for keeping data consistent and accurate across different survey questions. But technical issues and human errors can disrupt the survey process.
Make sure you document and thoroughly clarify the protocols to all interviewers. Also, use reliable data collection software, preferably with offline data collection, to avoid respondents dropping out because of technical issues or internet connection problems.
With quality control measures like recordings and observations, you can see if the survey went as planned and spot any discrepancies or mistakes.
For example, you can record phone interview sessions and review them later to check for adherence and competence. You can also observe the sessions in person or remotely with a checklist or a rating scale to evaluate the interviewer’s performance.
Calibration sessions reinforce survey key components, allow you to address any challenges, and ensure that the survey tool and interviewers are effective.
Let’s say you are researching how a new foundation fits different skin tones. Start by ensuring that all of the interviewers are asking the questions in the same way. This would ensure that the data that you collect is accurate and reliable.
Treatment fidelity ensures that the data is collected and analyzed accurately. If treatment fidelity is low, some factors may influence the participants’ behavior or responses.
For example, let’s say you are conducting a study on the effectiveness of a new teaching method. If treatment fidelity is low, some participants may not understand the question, and give off-handed responses.
This could lead to biased results, as the data would not be representative of the teaching method’s effectiveness. So you need to monitor and assess the survey’s treatment fidelity using various methods such as observation, self-report, or checklists.
Treatment fidelity documentation includes the survey protocol, tool, duration, sample, and other relevant information. It allows you and other researchers to identify and explain any discrepancies or unexpected results in your data.
You can also compare your results with other studies with similar interventions, and draw meaningful conclusions about their effectiveness.
The significance of treatment fidelity on survey outcomes and conclusions depends on how low it is. If it’s very low, the study results could be completely misleading.
However, if it is only slightly low, there is a high probability that response diversity is because of respondent opinions, and not other factors.
Treatment fidelity makes sure you’re collecting accurate, high-quality data allowing you to make informed, data-driven decisions. It also enables you to understand your audience and design more successful surveys.
However, achieving treatment fidelity has its challenges, but with the right survey tool and an in-depth analysis of data to identify areas of improvement, you can create better surveys and get reliable results.
Connect to Formplus, Get Started Now - It's Free!
You may also like:
Introduction Social research is a complex endeavor. It takes a lot of time, energy, and resources to gather data, analyze and present...
Omnibus surveys are a type of online survey that allows companies to conduct market research with a large number of participants while...
The Chi-Square test is a statistical test that is commonly used in surveys to determine whether there is a significant difference...
Have you opened a survey and noticed that some questions seem irrelevant or confusing? The survey description and questions don’t match....
